5730 RUDOLPH Avenue, St. Augustine, FL 32080 (MLS# 2136778)

5730 RUDOLPH Avenue, St. Augustine, FL 32080

$1,495,000
Property Type: Residential Bedrooms: 4 Baths: 4 Square Footage: 4,076 Lot Size (sq. ft.): 9,148 Status: Closed
Current Price: $1,495,000 List Date: 3/26/2026 Last Modified: 4/24/2026

Description

Some properties check a box or two. This one checks every single one. Set on a rare street to street lot running from Rudolph to Gloria on Anastasia Island, this solid concrete block home sits at a high elevation with exceptional dune protection and unobstructed Atlantic views that stop you in your tracks. Two fully independent units, each with two bedrooms and two bathrooms and their own private entrance, make this property equally compelling as a primary residence, a multigenerational compound, a vacation retreat, or a proven income producing investment. The upper level is the crown jewel. An open concept great room flows seamlessly from the gourmet kitchen through the dining and living areas and out to a rear deck where the Atlantic becomes your backdrop. The kitchen is anchored by a large granite island, custom tile work, and premium appliances.

Supplements: Outside, a hot tub, grilling station, and panoramic ocean vistas make the deck an extension of the living space rather than an afterthought. The ocean facing primary bedroom paired with its spa caliber en suite, soaking tub, and double glass enclosed shower is in a category of its own. The current owners use this level as their personal retreat and have rented only one bedroom while keeping the primary bedroom locked off entirely. The upside for a new owner willing to put both bedrooms into rotation is significant. The ground floor unit stands beautifully on its own. Polished concrete floors, an open kitchen and living layout, two well appointed bedrooms, and stylish bathrooms create a space that feels both modern and inviting. It has been a consistent and reliable performer as a short term rental. Beyond the two units, the property includes a regulation bocce ball court, a spacious garage with ample room for vehicles and all your beach gear, and a detached storage unit with its own mini split system that works perfectly as a private home office or climate controlled storage.Two outdoor showers, two private entrances, one extraordinary location. This is Anastasia Island living at its finest. Schedule your private showing today.

More Information MLS# 2136778

Contract Information

Current Price: $1,495,000 Property Sub Type: Single Family Residence Property Attached YN: No Status: Closed Sold Price: $1,495,000 Listing Contract Date: 2026-03-26

Location Tax and Legal

Street Number: 5730 Street Name: RUDOLPH Street Suffix: Avenue County: St. Johns State: FL Postal Code: 32080 MLS Area Major: 331-St Augustine Beach Subdivision Name: Butlers Beach

General Property Information

Bedrooms Total: 4 Bathrooms Full: 4 Bathrooms Total: 4 Living Area: 2016 Living Area Source: Public Records Building Area Total: 4076 Year Built: 1980 Accessory Dwelling Unit Y/N: Yes Homestead YN: Yes Lot Size Acres: 0.21 Lot Size Dimensions: 62 x 200 x 100 Association YN: No CDD Fee YN: No Accessibility Features YN: No New Construction YN: No Garage YN: Yes Garage Spaces: 1 Carport YN: No Pool Private YN: No Water Body Access YN: No Waterfront YN: No Furnished: Furnished Stories: 2 Entry Level: 2 Senior Community YN: No Directions: From I95S, east on 206, left on A1A, right on Mary St, right on Rudolph Ave. House is on the left/east side.Or coming from 207, right/south on A1A, to left on Mary St. Its 3 miles south of Marsh Cree Public Remarks: Some properties check a box or two. This one checks every single one. Set on a rare street to street lot running from Rudolph to Gloria on Anastasia Island, this solid concrete block home sits at a high elevation with exceptional dune protection and unobstructed Atlantic views that stop you in your tracks. Two fully independent units, each with two bedrooms and two bathrooms and their own private entrance, make this property equally compelling as a primary residence, a multigenerational compound, a vacation retreat, or a proven income producing investment. The upper level is the crown jewel. An open concept great room flows seamlessly from the gourmet kitchen through the dining and living areas and out to a rear deck where the Atlantic becomes your backdrop. The kitchen is anchored by a large granite island, custom tile work, and premium appliances. List Price/SqFt: 741.57 Sold Price/SqFt: 741.57

Status Change Information

Major Change Timestamp: 2026-04-24T18:00:09Z Major Change Type: Status Change Purchase Contract Date: 2026-03-29 Close Date: 2026-04-21 Close Price: 1495000

Accessory Dwelling Information

ADU Attached Y/N: Yes

Fireplace Features

Fireplaces Total: 1

DPR Eligible

DPR Eligible: No

Property Features

Levels: Two Rental Restrictions: No Minimum Appliances: Dishwasher; Dryer; Gas Range; Microwave; Refrigerator; Washer Fireplace Features: Gas Interior Features: Breakfast Bar; Ceiling Fan(s); In-Law Floorplan; Kitchen Island; Open Floorplan; Primary Bathroom -Tub with Separate Shower; Split Bedrooms Flooring: Tile; Vinyl Laundry Features: Upper Level Utilities: Cable Available; Electricity Connected; Sewer Connected; Water Connected Cooling: Central Air Heating: Central Water Source: Public Sewer: Public Sewer Security Features: Security Gate Construction Materials: Block; Concrete; Stucco Other Structures: Shed(s) Exterior Features: Balcony; Fire Pit Patio And Porch Features: Rear Porch Spa Features: Above Ground Roof: Shingle Parking Features: Attached; Garage Lot Features: Irregular Lot View: Beach; Ocean Fencing: Full Current Use: Residential; Single Family Road Surface Type: Paved Possession: Close Of Escrow Listing Terms: Cash; Conventional Contingency Reason: Financing; Inspection
Listing Office: THE NEWCOMER GROUP
Last Updated: April - 24 - 2026
Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.